Chasing the Wind

News. Faith. Nonsense.

Full Vs. Partial RSS Feeds

First, if you’re not some techy-geek, skip this post. Better yet, post a comment that says, “I have no idea what you’re talking about.” Make sure you click on one of the smiley faces that best describes your feelings.

Second, Dwight is running an experiment on Full versus Partial RSS feeds. You might be surprised I’m opinionated on this issue.

I love RSS feeds. I use Bloglines to keep them organized. I actually prefer Sharpreader, but Bloglines lets me read from two different computers without missing posts and without duplicates.

Oops. I accidentally loaded Sharpreader just now. Hold on. There.

I don’t mind partial RSS feeds; if the feed has an interesting first paragraph, I’ll happily click the link to read the rest. My advice to a commercial site that want advertising dollars: go with partial RSS feed. My advice to a non-commercial site: go with full RSS feed, give the readers everything.

My only gripe is bare-bones RSS feeds, like the one at Lonestartimes.com. Their RSS feed gives me the headline and then a 5 word summary, but neither the headline nor the summary give me any indication what the article is about. In other words, their RSS feed is completely useless. Here’s an example of today’s Lonestartimes feed:

Lonestartimes

Article: Edd Hendee recommends…
Summary: Edd Hendee recommends…
Posted on: Wed, Aug 17 2005 5:00AM

Article: Blogging Israel’s Gaza Disengagement
Summary: Blogging Israel
Posted on: Tue, Aug 16 2005 1:39PM

Article: I’m a festering boil!
Summary: Fun with libs
Posted on: Tue, Aug 16 2005 11:32 AM

Now, why would I click those articles? There’s not enough meat to it to tell me what I’m about to click on. Toss in the fact that Lonestartimes ignores trackbacks and won’t include links to other blogs, there’s not even a carrot to entice me there.

Let’s compare it to Dwight’s article:

TechBlog
Upgrade your geek with Dwight Silverman

Article: You want full-feed? You got it . . . for now
By Dwight on RSS

Summary: As I’ve written before, there’s a running debate on the Web regarding the merits of full vs. partial RSS feeds. A full feed gets you the entire text of a post in your RSS reader; a partial feed delivers just…

Posted on: Tue, Aug 16 2005 2:25

So much better. I know it’s only 2 sentences, but it’s enough to tell me what the article is about.

I clicked Dwight’s article. I haven’t clicked on any Lonestartimes articles in weeks.

, , , , ,

Posted by:

Michael

Follower of Jesus, conservative, freedom-loving patriot.

11 responses to “Full Vs. Partial RSS Feeds”

  1. Jo Avatar
    Jo

    Huh? 😕

    Like

    Reply
  2. Vox Avatar
    Vox

    I am a big fan of the full feed. I like being able to quickly get through my blog reading, and with the full feed I get all the meat with none of the bells and whistles that slow down loading. There are a few site that only send partial feeds, like Lori’s, that I care enough to read and so I have Sharpreader set to automatically load the whole article. But it is SLOW because of all the pretty stuff she has on her site, and I would prefer to just get the facts.

    But I’m a geek and I prefer simple anyway. I prefer sites with minimal overhead, quick load times…..

    BTW: for those not familiar with the full feed, any images in your post come through, just not all the images on your site.

    Like

    Reply
  3. Michael Avatar
    Michael

    I don’t mind the click; the partial feeds usually give me enough information. Usually.

    I wish I could figure out how to set Sharpreader up on 2 separate computers, but 1 account though.

    Like

    Reply
  4. Rodney Olsen Avatar
    Rodney Olsen

    I publish a full feed of my posts. I thought about doing the partial thing so that more people would click through to my site but then I thought that if I’m only posting to get site hits I might as well give up now. I prefer to do whatever makes life easier for those who are kind enough to be reading my posts in whatever way they choose to do that.

    Like

    Reply
  5. Stephen Avatar
    Stephen

    I have no idea what you’re talking about. 😕

    Like

    Reply
  6. Michael Avatar
    Michael

    Rodney: I’m actually not sure why I’d want more people to click through my site. I don’t do any advertising, so RSS feeds accomplish almost the same thing.

    Stephen: It’s ok. Here’s a cookie.

    Like

    Reply
  7. Diane Avatar
    Diane

    Oh my gosh, I actually know what yawl are talking about. It must be that tecky guy I married rubbing off on me!

    Like

    Reply
  8. Michael Avatar
    Michael

    You’re starting to think like me? Uh oh. 😛

    Like

    Reply
  9. kevin whited Avatar
    kevin whited

    I don’t offer full feedson my sites for one reason — I’m more interested in building somewhat of a community (however small) and having conversation than making things easier for readers.

    I want readers who will come over, read the post, read the comments, and join the conversation. If that’s too much trouble — fine, nobody has to come read the content I’m providing for free.

    But that’s my bargain. That’s what I want out of the effort. I don’t think it’s unreasonable. 🙂

    Like

    Reply
  10. Michael Avatar
    Michael

    Kevin, I took a look at your RSS feed and it’s fine – I get enough from your summary and headline to determine if I want to click an article. And I don’t mind clicking if I know I’ll find something useful.

    The only RSS feed recently that frustrates me is the Lonestartimes.com feed which is too short and way too vague.

    Like

    Reply
  11. Doug Avatar
    Doug

    I just switched to full, and it is bugging me how much room it takes on the sidebar of Bloglines. I do believe I’ll be switching back. I can see the reasons for both sides of the argument, really. I’d like it if the RSS readers would show a preset length of a post so the user can determine how much they want at a time, then I would just keep it with a full post.

    As it is now, I feel that I’m crowding others out. 😆

    Like

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Michael Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. ( Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. ( Log Out /  Change )

Cancel

Connecting to %s

About Me

Michael, a sinner saved by grace, sharing what the good Lord has shared with me.

Solomon, in the book of Ecclesiastes, said, “I have seen all the things that are done under the sun; all of them are meaningless, a chasing after the wind.”

If you’re not living for the glory of God, then what you’re doing is meaningless, no matter what it is. Living for God gives life meaning, and enjoying a “chasing after the wind” is a gift from God. I’m doing what I can to enjoy this gift daily.

Got questions? I’m not surprised. If you have any questions about Chasing the Wind, you can email me at chasingthewind@outlook.com.

Recent Posts

  • God’s Plan for You
    I.      Jeremiah the Prophet We’re starting a new book today, a study of the major prophet Jeremiah.  We’re going to find over the course of the next several months much about the character of Jeremiah, and more importantly, the character of God. The book itself is long.  By word count, it’s the longest book in […]
  • It Is Finished
    The price Jesus paid for us, sinners in a broken world, was immense. It is available to all today. Accept the forgiveness so freely given. You don’t have to do anything else to be a Christian. Tetelstai, It Is Finished. #Jesus #biblestudy #love
  • Jesus Prays
    Jesus prays to the Father – for Himself, for His disciples, for future believes. He prays for you, too. Will you answer? #Jesus #hope #believe #pray #biblestudy
  • I Am the True Vine
       I.      Introduction Jesus made 7 “I am” statement in the book of John.  Do you remember what they were? This Passover week, we are at the 7th and final “I AM” statement.  During the first 6, Jesus gave these “I AM” statements to explain His relationship with the Father, and His relationship with us.  […]
  • His Hour Has Come
      I.      Introduction Even though we’re still in the book of John, something is different.  Jesus has demonstrated seven major miracles, each one demonstrating Jesus is the true Messiah.  But He has completed His miracles, and now he will elaborate on His death and what it means for gentiles.  But before we go there, I […]

Newsletter

%d bloggers like this: