Middle Class Military

Charles Rangel, the looney left-wing Democrat, has criticized the military on several issues, one of them that the military is made up disproportionately of minorities while middle and upper class families reap the benefits without risk.

Where he got that idea from, who knows. Certainly didn’t come from the facts, though. Turns out most of the military volunteers come from middle class families.

Researchers matched the ZIP codes of recruits over the past five years with federal government estimates of household incomes in those neighborhoods. Contrary to complaints from some liberal lawmakers and pundits, the data show that the poor are not shouldering the bulk of the military’s need for new soldiers, airmen, sailors and Marines.

The poorest neighborhoods provided 18 percent of recruits in prewar 1999 and 14.6 percent in 2003. By contrast, areas where household incomes ranged from $30,000 to $200,000 provided more than 85 percent.

“We found that recruits tend to come from middle-class areas, with disproportionately fewer from low-income areas,” said the report, prepared by Tim Kane, an Air Force Academy graduate and economics scholar. “Overall, the income distribution of military enlistees is more similar to than different from the income distribution of the general population.”

Turns out they’re better educated than the average American, too:

Mr. Kane said overall evidence “is at odds with the image, painted by some supporters of the draft, that the military exploits poor, ignorant young Americans by using slick advertising that promises technical careers in the military to dupe them into trading their feeble opportunities in the private sector for a meager role as cannon fodder.”

About 98 percent of all enlistees from 1999 to 2003 had a high school diploma, compared with 75 percent of nonrecruits nationwide.

“In an education context, rather than attracting underprivileged young Americans, the military seems to be attracting above-average Americans,” Mr. Kane wrote.

Just something that warmed my heart, knowing my son returns from Army basic training tomorrow. 🙂

* Tip from Brutally Honest. About the news article, I mean, not the news about my son.

4 thoughts on “Middle Class Military

  1. When I signed up, I’ll admit I didn’t know much about my particular job, but if anything, they toned it down more than they spruced it up. They classified my job to something akin to admin.

    My actual job? I’m in JAG, performing duties similar to what I did for free on Varsity Debate back in High School.

    We’re constantly stressed to about the importance of education. It’s almost impossible to advance beyond the ranks of Private (PVT, PV2, and PFC) without some form of higher education.

    I’m proud to have joined, and I wish and pray that others would stop treating my existance (along with my Battle Buddies’) as a politcal tool.


  2. Now that they have those statistics, do you suppose the cry will be that the military is sacrificing the best and the brightest? “How dare you take educated youngsters with a promising future and turn them into cannon fodder?”


  3. Vox – no doubt, that’ll be the refrain next year, though I’m not sure liberals are concerned about the best and brightest.

    And AMM, my son, is coming home tonight!


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s