Chasing the Wind

News. Faith. Nonsense.

Mechanical Investing News

The Mechanical Investing strategy I’ve been following since 1998 is in the news at the Motley Fool today. Here are some excerpts, part 1 of 2:

Want 50% Annual Returns?
By Jim Fink (TMF Hamp)
January 30, 2006

In my years of reading The Motley Fool, I’ve been particularly interested in the Fool boards on “mechanical investing,” which discuss stock-picking strategies based on quantitative computer screens. This type of investing is “mechanical” because it requires the investor to pick stocks based on an objective set of fundamental (e.g., annual sales above $500 million) and/or technical (e.g., stock price above the 200-day moving average) criteria. Furthermore, there is literally no discretion on the part of the investor; if the screen spits out Altria (NYSE: MO), you buy the stock regardless of whether you morally oppose tobacco companies, or think that litigation will bankrupt the company. So goes the strategy, anyway.

Some might argue that it’s a form of brain-dead investing, but what’s wrong with that? I’ll take money however it comes to me. As Fool contributor Tim Beyers also recently pointed out, it’s not uncommon for individual investors to have a difficult time deciding how many stocks to own. It’s similarly difficult to endure the emotional roller coaster of a high-volatility portfolio. While Tim was advocating the Motley Fool Champion Funds newsletter as a solution, mechanical investing is another way to save us from our more irrational, emotional selves.

There are a few simple rules of thumb for developing a logical stock screen. Fool member moebruin wrote an article to help us determine which stock-screen criteria probably have purely coincidental superior investment returns (and thus should be avoided), and which criteria have a logical underpinning that gives us confidence in their continued superior investing returns. His five criteria for a “good” stock screen are:

  1. The strategy must follow a simple and logical protocol;
  2. The rationale must make sense and be easily explainable;
  3. The screen must work with good but diminishing returns for lower-ranked stocks;
  4. There must be at least 10 years of historic returns (for purposes of backtesting, to confirm validity);
  5. There should be peripheral data that supports the contention that the screens should work.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

About Me

Solomon, in the book of Ecclesiastes, said, “I have seen all the things that are done under the sun; all of them are meaningless, a chasing after the wind.”

If you’re not living for the glory of God, then what you’re doing is meaningless, no matter what it is. Living for God gives life meaning, and enjoying a “chasing after the wind” is a gift from God. I’m doing what I can to enjoy this gift daily.

Got questions? I’m not surprised. If you have any questions about Chasing the Wind, you can email me at

Recent Posts

  • His Hour Has Come
      I.      Introduction Even though we’re still in the book of John, something is different.  Jesus has demonstrated seven major miracles, each one demonstrating Jesus is the true Messiah.  But He has completed His miracles, and now he will elaborate on His death and what it means for gentiles.  But before we go there, I […]
  • He Knows His Own
    Our Shepherd knows His sheep. Do you know Him? Listen for His voice. #Jesus #Shepherd #BibleStudy #Sunday
  • Bread of Life
      I.      Introduction Who does Jesus say He is? The book of John describes Jesus beautifully, beginning with verse 1, “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.”  But I want to skip to verses 9-13 because it gives a nice introduction to our lesson today. […]
  • But Whoever Drinks
    The source of all forgiveness and hope is found in the living water offered to all through our Lord Christ Jesus. #biblestudy #LivingWater #Hope #Jesus
  • Where Do We Find Hope?
    Today is our conclusion of our study of minor prophets. First Amos, then Jonah and Hosea, and now Micah. That is four by my count, but there are a total of 12 minor prophets. No doubt we will return to Joel, Obadiah, Habakkuk and the others, but next week we open the New Testament book […]


%d bloggers like this: